In our world there are many views of any occurrence. If the language is shared, it helps in understanding what someone is saying. Unfortunately we are often left shaking our heads as we try to put the words of a notable person together with the history of actions we have seen over the years. We are further confused when we see our world and it differs from a popular view by others not in our world. When we encounter such, they must be attended to.
Here is a fine example of attending from South Africa. A guest blog from Nadine. The original post is “Letters To A Rockstar” and located here. Her particulars can be found here
Dear Bono,
I imagine you have woken up this morning feeling like you are either the world’s biggest idiot, or the world’s most misunderstood man. I imagine bits of both are true, so I thought maybe you might appreciate a bit of a girl-on-the-street explanation.
Right now you find yourself in a bit of a broken country. It has been twenty years but we are still healing, we’re wobbling on our feet and often failing miserably, but patriotic people like myself are hopeful. We love South Africa. We love her vibe. We love her culture. We love biltong and boerworse and braaing. We love Ouma Rusks and chocolate eclair toffees and koeksisters. And Barry Hilton and Casper De Vries. We have this country with mountains of riches to offer, all worthy of preservation. And yet so many still struggle…
We have this history that refuses to live in the past. Instead it dominates our present and threatens our future. The radicals in this country may not trek around with guns as they do in so many northern African countries, but they do have this powerful voice that sings of all these wonderful things that never get delivered. These radicals prey on the poor and uneducated masses, poisoning their minds with so many lies. It is these people who believe that black people hating white people does not constitute racism. You’re only a racist if you hate black people. And the new message seems to be that if you’re white, you’re automatically one.
Now I will give you the benefit of the doubt and conclude that you said something stupid and have possibly been misunderstood. I will further say that in NO context WHATSOEVER is racism or hate speech of ANY kind acceptable. It should be no more acceptable in a small private gathering as it should be in a rally to hype up the masses. What was possibly a flippant remark on your part can also be misinterpreted on the other end of the spectrum and be used as a validation for this kind of behaviour. Julius Malema scared the crap out of a lot of South Africans not too long ago. Now most of us take him with a pinch of salt and a sense of humor, but not two years ago he had us wondering about our safety. This is the man you have accidentally (I hope) aligned yourself with. I can guarantee you the man got a kick out of having Bono agree with him.
What you say is gospel to millions of people. You are a respected celebrity, and known as a man of peaceful politics and generous philanthropy. Your opinion here is out of line, and was clearly made out of complete ignorance. But you know what? Your thoughtless comment (out of context or not) made my whole country wake up and scream for what they believed was right, so as wrong as you were, and as angry and disappointed as I was yesterday, I am proud of my country for going against you and for standing up for their beliefs. Nobody bought yours.
I am extra proudly South African today.
Footnote: AfriForum has come out to say that they support Bono’s statement that it is stupid to sing these kinds of struggle songs in public. Are we supposed to be relieved by this? Shit I’m sorry but maybe I’m just so naive that I automatically thought that particular sentiment would go without saying. Never mind that this particular statement is not what we take issue with! It’s the idea that hate speech-type songs have their place in our current society AT ALL. How is it possible that this is so difficult to grasp? As for sensationalism – of COURSE there’s a crapload of sensationalism going around! Something dumb was said – and the masses rallied together and were appalled by the sentiment of it! Blame the reporters as much as you want for “quoting him out of context” if you must, but I would just very much appreciate it if you would back your statement with the ACTUAL acceptable context. Like really – it is ok to sing about killing white people in the comfort of your home? Is THAT the acceptable context? And if I teach my kid that it’s ok to, I dunno, hate hispanic people, as long as it’s only from the comfort of his bedroom? Is this the context we’re talking about? You’re saying Bono has been “absolved” – but this absolution has come in the form of repeating the initial article almost word for word. Huh????? How does that change anything?
He said something dumb. I very much doubt he meant it that way, and yes the media lapped it up and had it’s proverbial field day. And?
You know – perhaps our ancestors wouldn’t allow black people to use the same bathroom as them, or eat in the same restaurants. Maybe they enforced a curfew. And didn’t allow them proper housing. But you know what? From that same generation came a bunch of ancestors who FOUGHT for freedom. And in THIS generation that freedom is revered and appreciated. You no longer get to sing songs about killing people. It goes completely against what many of our forefathers – black AND white – fought for.
End of story.
I leave you finally with a quote from Pastor Martin Niemoller:
“First they came for the communists,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a communist.Then they came for the trade unionists,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a trade unionist.Then they came for the Jews,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a Jew.Then they came for me
and there was no one left to speak out for me.”
Visit Nadine at her blog http://www.passingtheopenwindows.co.za/